Dose Coefficients for External Exposures to Environmental Sources


Draft document: Dose Coefficients for External Exposures to Environmental Sources
Submitted by Fumiaki TAKAHASHI, JAEA
Commenting as an individual

1. Chapter 2

 

  The sentences in L.595-599 explain the limitation of a conversion coefficient of 0.7 (Sv/Bq) to estimate effective dose for public. It is better to add some explanations about the limitation for usage of this value.

/ UNSCEAR has adopted this value since UNSCEAR report 1982. At that time, the “effective dose equivalent” (not effective dose) was given to estimate exposure dose.

 

/ The limitation can be also assumed from some previous publications (e.g., Peteoussi (1991) in L.2424-2425 and Saito (1990) in L.2428-2431; these two publications are referred in UNSCEAR report 1993). 

2. Chapter 8

 

1) This publication is to be useful to establish an emergency planning for a radiological accident or an emergency response.

 

  I recommend to list the effective dose rate coefficients for some radionuclides in the main text. Here, the candidate nuclides are Cs-137, Cs-134, Te-129m and Ag-110 for soil contamination, because these nuclides are detected a few months after the accident at the Fukushima Dai-ich Nuclear Power Plant. Please see the references in L.2391-2393 (Mikami, 2015) and in L.2444-2447 (Saito, 2015).

 

 

 

2) The data in this publication are also useful to assess radiation dose due to from terrestrial gamma rays from radionuclides in nature.

 

   So, I also recommend to list the effective dose rate coefficients for K-40 and Tl-208 in the main text


Back